Is Megadeth's "So Far, So Good..." Their Most Underrated Album?

oldstore.com Team Editor

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Feb 13, 2025

63 visitor like this post

Share

Is Megadeth's "So Far, So Good... So What!" Their Most Underrated Album?

Megadeth. The name alone conjures images of blistering guitar solos, Dave Mustaine's snarling vocals, and complex, thrash metal anthems. While albums like Rust in Peace and Countdown to Extinction often dominate "best of" lists, a strong argument can be made for So Far, So Good... So What! as their most underrated masterpiece. Released in 1988, this album sits in a fascinating middle ground, bridging the raw energy of their earlier work with the more polished production of their later successes. But is it truly underrated, or does its place in Megadeth's discography deserve its current standing?

A Transitional Masterpiece

So Far, So Good... So What! marked a significant turning point for Megadeth. Following the departure of guitarist Chris Poland and bassist David Ellefson (temporarily), Mustaine rebuilt the lineup with Jeff Young on guitar and James LoMenzo on bass. This shift in personnel is palpable throughout the album. While retaining the aggression that defines Megadeth, the songwriting displays a newfound complexity and maturity. Tracks like "In My Darkest Hour" showcase a more melodic sensibility than previously heard, while others like "Hook in Mouth" still deliver the blistering thrash Megadeth fans crave.

Musical Prowess and Songwriting Depth

The album's musical strength lies in its diversity. It's not just a collection of thrash metal bangers; it's a journey through various shades of metal. "Liar", with its memorable riff and powerful chorus, is a prime example of this diversity. The instrumental track, "Anarchy in the U.K." (a Sex Pistols cover), demonstrates the band's technical proficiency, showcasing Young's impressive guitar work. This range is what sets So Far, So Good... So What! apart from some of Megadeth's more focused releases.

The Underrated Factor

So, why is it considered underrated? Perhaps it's the shadow cast by the monumental success of Rust in Peace. The latter album refined the formula established on So Far, So Good... So What!, achieving a level of commercial and critical acclaim that often overshadows its predecessor. However, So Far, So Good... So What! laid the groundwork for that future success. It's the album where Megadeth truly started to hone their signature sound, experimenting with different approaches while staying true to their aggressive core.

Beyond the Music: A Look at the Context

The album's release also coincided with a period of significant change within the band. Mustaine's personal struggles, alongside the lineup shifts, contributed to its unique atmosphere. This raw energy, born from a time of transition and internal conflict, imbues the music with a powerful rawness and authenticity that many fans find captivating. It's a testament to Mustaine's resilience and artistic vision.

Comparing to Megadeth's Canon

When comparing So Far, So Good... So What! to other Megadeth albums, its position becomes clearer. While Peace Sells... but Who's Buying?, Rust in Peace, and Countdown to Extinction have garnered immense praise and critical recognition, So Far, So Good... So What! presents a different kind of appeal. It offers a glimpse into the band's evolution, a snapshot of a band finding its footing and experimenting with its sound while creating intensely memorable music.

Conclusion: A Case for Underrated Status

Ultimately, whether or not So Far, So Good... So What! is Megadeth's most underrated album is subjective. However, the compelling arguments for its underrated status are undeniable. Its diverse songwriting, impressive musicianship, and the historical context surrounding its creation all contribute to its enduring appeal. It's an album that rewards repeated listens, revealing new layers of complexity and nuance with each playthrough. For many Megadeth fans, it’s not just an album; it's a crucial chapter in the band's incredible story, and a testament to their enduring legacy. So, crank it up, revisit this classic, and decide for yourself – is So Far, So Good... So What! truly Megadeth’s most underrated album?